Looking for ways to improve your OTIF scorecard and eliminate fines? Our Walmart supply chain experts help suppliers like you each week! Click for a FREE consultation.
Walmart has a variety of systems, initiatives, and metrics in place to keep its supply chain efficient. Suppliers are monitored and measured on the accuracy of deliveries to keep the store shelves full and costs low. One initiative that Walmart uses to streamline the supply chain process is OTIF.
In this article, we’ll define OTIF, look at how it’s calculated, and explain OTIF compliance requirements. We’ll also discuss ways to avoid paying penalties for non-compliance and other frequently asked questions.
What is Walmart OTIF?
Walmart OTIF stands for On Time In Full. Walmart uses the OTIF initiative to measure the supply chain performance of its suppliers on two metrics:
-
-
- On Time – the supplier’s shipment must arrive at the Walmart distribution center or store within the specified delivery window (no sooner or later)
- In Full – the supplier’s shipment must have all items Walmart ordered (no more and no less)
-
If a supplier fails to meet the OTIF requirements, a chargeback is issued for non-compliance.
What are the compliance requirements for OTIF?
Walmart calculates On Time and In Full as two separate metrics. As of 2025, Walmart expects both prepaid and collect suppliers to meet OTIF goals:
-
-
- Prepaid Suppliers (supplier ships freight) – 90% on time delivery, 95% in full delivery
- Collect Suppliers (Walmart ships freight) – 98% collect ready, 95% in full delivery
-
To calculate a supplier’s On Time score, Walmart uses this formula:
On Time % = (Number of On-Time Cases ÷ Total Shipped Cases) × 100
For example, if Walmart orders 500 cases, but only 450 arrive at the warehouse on time, the score is:
450 ÷ 500 = .9
.9 x 100 = 90% On Time
To calculate a supplier’s In Full score, Walmart uses this formula:
In Full % = (Number of Cases Delivered In-Full ÷ Total Ordered Cases) × 100
For example, if Walmart orders 800 cases, but only 650 arrive in the shipment, the score is:
650 ÷ 800 = .8125
.8125 x 100 = 81.25% In Full
How much is a Walmart OTIF fine or penalty?
When a supplier fails to meet Walmart’s OTIF guidelines, they receive a chargeback in the amount of 3% of the cost of goods (COGS) for each case in violation. The 3% COGS chargeback can apply to any case that is:
-
- Incomplete (not delivered in full)
-
Early (delivered too soon)
-
Late (not delivered on time)
For example, if a supplier ships $500,000 worth of goods but $10,000 worth are incomplete or late, the COGS fine is $300 (3% of $10,000).
How can I prevent Walmart OTIF fines?
Walmart suppliers should constantly review each step in their supply chain to find areas to improve. Making small adjustments can amount to huge savings in chargebacks across the board. A few things suppliers can do to eliminate chargebacks include:
Prioritize Complete Order Fulfillment
Some suppliers don’t realize it immediately, but one incomplete load can result in multiple fines from Walmart. Failing on the In Full metric is one fine, plus the shipment quantity not matching the purchase order quantity is a separate fine under the Supplier Quality Excellence Program (SQEP). On top of that, Walmart may fine the supplier for the unused space on their truck in routing.
Walmart suppliers can save thousands each quarter by ensuring loads are complete and match the purchase order before leaving their facilities.
Hit the Walmart Delivery Window
Another way to avoid penalties is to deliver shipments within the designated time slots issued by Walmart. A good practice is to partner with a 3PL company that specializes in Walmart logistics and understands the on time expectation.
Examine Internal Communication Processes
Walmart suppliers should have a seamless communication channel between their logistics teams, warehouse staff, and salespeople. Countless mistakes can be avoided with clear communication and a common portal to track and verify direction on each shipment.
Research and Dispute Walmart Penalties
Walmart understands that mistakes happen, even on their side of some transactions. The company has systems and processes in place for suppliers to dispute chargebacks, deductions, and other fines. It’s up to suppliers to review and thoroughly research each fine and understand the process for a dispute.
If suppliers don’t have the time or resources to research Walmart fines, 5G Consulting offers a FREE consultation and review.
Save All Documentation
While Walmart will accept and refund a penalty dispute, suppliers must make their case! Save every piece of documentation for each transaction.
During a dispute, Walmart may require shipping confirmations, purchase orders, receipts, and email communications with the merchant team
Walmart OTIF Frequently asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: What is Walmart’s OTIF program?
A: OTIF stands for On Time In Full. Walmart uses OTIF to measure supplier performance based on timely and complete deliveries.
Q: Why does Walmart use OTIF?
A: Walmart launched OTIF to improve its supply chain, reduce the number of out-of-stocks, keep inventory integrity, and ultimately improve the customer experience.
Q: What is the current OTIF compliance goal for suppliers?
A: As of 2025, the metrics Walmart expects suppliers to hit are:
-
-
- Prepaid Suppliers (supplier ships freight) – 90% on time delivery, 95% in full delivery
- Collect Suppliers (Walmart ships freight) – 98% collect ready, 95% in full delivery
-
Q: How does Walmart define On Time?
A: A Walmart delivery is considered on time if it arrives within the assigned delivery window as scheduled by Walmart.
Q: How does Walmart define In Full?
A: A Walmart delivery is in full if it contains 100% of the items ordered (no shortages or overages).
Q: What happens if a supplier fails to meet OTIF goals?
A: Walmart issues financial penalties (chargebacks) for late, early, extra, or incomplete shipments. These can impact supplier scorecards and profit margins.
Q: How are OTIF scores calculated?
A: Scores are calculated by dividing the number of compliant cases or orders by the total cases or orders expected, separately for on time and in full goals.
Q: Where can suppliers access OTIF scores and reports?
A: Suppliers can view OTIF performance in Retail Link, specifically in the OTIF Scorecard Tool.
Q: What are the chargeback fees for non-compliance?
A: Walmart typically charges 3% of the cost of goods for late or incomplete deliveries.
Q: What are the most common reasons for OTIF fines?
A: Walmart suppliers will ususally receive OTIF fines due to:
-
-
- Carrier delays
- Warehouse picking/packing errors
- Miscommunication about delivery windows
- Order fill rate issues
- Unconfirmed appointments
-
Q: Can suppliers dispute OTIF fines?
A: Yes. Suppliers can dispute OTIF chargebacks through Retail Link within a set timeframe (typically 90 days).
Q: How does OTIF differ for collect vs. prepaid suppliers?
A: Prepaid suppliers are responsible for on time delivery and fill rate.
Collect suppliers are monitored more on order readiness and fill rate, while Walmart controls transportation.
Q: Are there any tools to help improve OTIF performance?
A: Yes. Suppliers can use Retail Link, Supplier One, transportation dashboards, and third-party compliance tools to monitor and improve performance.
Q: Can partial shipments meet OTIF standards?
A: No. Partial shipments fail the in full requirement, even if delivered on time.
Q: How often are OTIF metrics updated?
A: OTIF performance data is updated weekly, with month-to-date summaries and historical performance trends.
Learn More From 5G!
Want to learn more about preventing OTIF fines? Need help in disputing current fines? The supply chain compliance team at 5G will review your current processes and reporting to put those dollars back on your bottom line.
A consultation is absolutely FREE! Click here to set up a call and learn more.